Score: 4

"Short"

submission: Phoenix Wrong Big Boys

date: June 16, 2008

Short, and the sound is way too soft (or at least soft compared to the hammer fall - i never know with my computer). Still, other than the sound thing there's nothing wrong with it as part of a Phoenix wrong. Synching and animation was fine. I just like a bit more to sink my teeth into.

Score: 8

"up and down"

submission: Ultimate Ace Attorney FF

date: June 11, 2008

Some of that was pretty good, some kinda huh. But you know what? TOTALLY worth watching just for the start and end scenes. I heart them so hard it hurts. Especially puppy-dog-eyes Phoenix. Plz hurry with that scene selection.

Score: 9

"Awesomely fantastic!"

submission: Less Than Three

date: October 16, 2007

The main problem being that now my (RL) girlfriend wont stop singing it... all the time... all the time....

Score: 7

"Ooh, this could be fun"

submission: Xionic Madness - Trailer

date: August 28, 2007

Cute syle! I think there's a lot to be said for the 'simplicity' of the original madness films, so disagree with the guy who would call it an evolution. That said, this should give an opportunity to do something similarly cool but in a completely different direction.

Score: 10

"Top quality"

submission: Animator vs. Animation II

date: March 16, 2007

I disagree that you topped the last one, but still absolutely top quality work, and definatley worthy of its name :). Good luck with any future project i guess.

Score: 4

"Should at least do that much."

submission: Phoenix Wrong : JFR

date: March 5, 2007

It's not like it involves particularly complicated animation, so i do think you should at least have that working properly, and not all jittery like. That said i highly approve of your 'powdered toast man' bit.

Score: 7

"Can you hear the thunder?"

submission: "Lost"

date: November 5, 2006

Ahh, i do love ska. We have this pub down the street that has live ska bands Wednesdays. And being a student that's a GREAT day to go pubbing...

PS, kudos on actually getting the side of the rode right. Apparently we're exposed to so much American TV down here we get it wrong as often as not, so says my acting friends.

Score: 7

"In two minds"

submission: Evil Nick's Phoenix Wrong

date: November 1, 2006

On one hand, you can't be credited with the idea which was the most important thing really. On the other you don't pretend to, and have made an *excellent*... tribute? So i guess regardless of anything else i can say i enjoyed it and you certainly managed to do what you set out to very well.

Score: 4

"Well.."

submission: Birdhouse short

date: October 29, 2006

Not bad graphics/animation stylings at all. Might well get through. But of course, a flash needs more than that. You know, a point. Story, voices... The good news of course being that if you have a story to tell you have the tools to tell it.

Score: 10

"You sirs, just raised the bar!"

submission: BR's Climate Chaos

date: October 28, 2006

Salute!

Almost completely destroyed my computer actually running the thing, but totally worth it! This just drips raw liquid innovation.